When a student goes to college and sets up their schedule, they get to pick their professors. The way many students do this is by looking at how the teacher rates either on an internal system at their college or through web sites like Rate My Professor. However, there is increasing evidence that how a student feels about a professor has little to do with how good of an instructor that professor really is. According to Inside Higher Ed, New study could be another nail in the coffin for the validity of student evaluations of teaching, a number of studies suggest that student evaluations of professors’ teaching are unreliable at best. You could compare it to a friend’s review of a restaurant. He may love it and highly recommend it. Yet when you go to the restaurant, you have the exact opposite experience. In essence, just because a student or students like a professor, doesn’t mean she is a good professor and conversely, poor ratings do not mean a professor is a bad instructor.
So how does a student determine who the best professor is for a class they have to take? Go speak to the professor yourself and ask for their syllabus (a document that outlines everything you need to do for that semester). This is a great strategy because 1) rarely do students engage in such proactive efforts to ensure their education is maximized, giving your potential professor a very good impression of you before you are even in her class; 2) it’s actions like this to lead to additional actions and the development of a professional skill set that employers are desperately seeking in college graduates; and 3) this simple step can save you from a semester of frustration.
Bottom line, think of each class as a $2,000 investment and try to get your monies worth. Do this by asking questions with enough lead time so you can make the absolute best decision for you. Finally, a friends recommendation is great but ask them questions too. An easy “A” is not what you are looking for. You are looking for that professor that you will love because you become inspired. That’s your ideal professor.
PS: That’s me in the picture…blue shirt and bald as bald can be!
Steven J. Harvey, Ph.D.
CEO & Founder, My College Max, Web Site: www.mycollegemax.com
Executive Director, The WNY Consortium of Higher Education, Web Site: www.wnycollegeconnection.com